From: john smith on
Yeah Nix thought he had it and Conrad thought he had caught it because
he saw it hit Nix's glove. That doesn't change the fact that Nix's glove
was near the top of the wall or if not above the wall when his glove
made contact with the ball. It would have been a really nice catch. I
still say it was going to be a homerun. For a guy like Conrad to drive a
ball the other way that far off Cordero just makes you scratch your
head...

From: RJA on
On May 20, 5:00 pm, tom dunne <dunn...(a)gmail.com> wrote:
> On May 20, 4:49 pm, eddyg...(a)msn.com (john smith) wrote:
>
> > I would agree they need a closer. He has been very very shaky, even when
> > he gets the save. This isn't a knee jerk reaction either. I lobbied last
> > year for them to get rid of Harang and Cordero and I said keep Arroyo.
> > Rhodes has been the only lights out guy all year down there and he is
> > very old. You start overusing him and that is only going to bring his
> > performance down as well.
>
> Cordero is SECOND IN THE LEAGUE in saves.  If Laynce Nix isn't out
> there playing volleyball with the bases loaded, he saves today's
> game.  This bullpen is shaky because Nick Masset is pitching horribly
> and innings are going to guys like Ondrusek and Fisher.  Cordero is
> not the problem.

I think you have to admit that Cordero has been shaky at times. Save
situations are often forgiving. That game vs. St.Louis last weekend
is a good example.
From: tom dunne on
On May 20, 9:35 pm, RJA <agentvau...(a)gmail.com> wrote:
> On May 20, 5:00 pm, tom dunne <dunn...(a)gmail.com> wrote:
>
> > On May 20, 4:49 pm, eddyg...(a)msn.com (john smith) wrote:
>
> > > I would agree they need a closer. He has been very very shaky, even when
> > > he gets the save. This isn't a knee jerk reaction either. I lobbied last
> > > year for them to get rid of Harang and Cordero and I said keep Arroyo..
> > > Rhodes has been the only lights out guy all year down there and he is
> > > very old. You start overusing him and that is only going to bring his
> > > performance down as well.
>
> > Cordero is SECOND IN THE LEAGUE in saves.  If Laynce Nix isn't out
> > there playing volleyball with the bases loaded, he saves today's
> > game.  This bullpen is shaky because Nick Masset is pitching horribly
> > and innings are going to guys like Ondrusek and Fisher.  Cordero is
> > not the problem.
>
> I think you have to admit that Cordero has been shaky at times.  Save
> situations are often forgiving.  That game vs. St.Louis last weekend
> is a good example.

Yeah, sure, no doubt about that. Nearly every player has stretches
during the season where he's not on his game, and Coco isn't airtight
in the 9th right now. On the other hand, saying that "they need a
closer" makes me wonder what team some people are watching. The Reds'
other relievers outside Rhodes have been unreliable, the defense at
shortstop is weak, there's an offensive black hole out in center
field, and the bats off the bench include Paul Janish and Miguel
Cairo. I worry about ALL of that before I worry about a closer who
has averaged 39 saves the last three years and is on pace to save 51
games this year.

That's not a bullshit number. If the save chances keep up, Cordero is
literally saving games at a rate of 51 for the year. Even accounting
for a drop in opportunities, he's almost sure to save 40-plus. This
guy ain't the problem.
From: RJA on
On May 20, 11:33 pm, tom dunne <dunn...(a)gmail.com> wrote:
> On May 20, 9:35 pm, RJA <agentvau...(a)gmail.com> wrote:
>
>
>
>
>
> > On May 20, 5:00 pm, tom dunne <dunn...(a)gmail.com> wrote:
>
> > > On May 20, 4:49 pm, eddyg...(a)msn.com (john smith) wrote:
>
> > > > I would agree they need a closer. He has been very very shaky, even when
> > > > he gets the save. This isn't a knee jerk reaction either. I lobbied last
> > > > year for them to get rid of Harang and Cordero and I said keep Arroyo.
> > > > Rhodes has been the only lights out guy all year down there and he is
> > > > very old. You start overusing him and that is only going to bring his
> > > > performance down as well.
>
> > > Cordero is SECOND IN THE LEAGUE in saves.  If Laynce Nix isn't out
> > > there playing volleyball with the bases loaded, he saves today's
> > > game.  This bullpen is shaky because Nick Masset is pitching horribly
> > > and innings are going to guys like Ondrusek and Fisher.  Cordero is
> > > not the problem.
>
> > I think you have to admit that Cordero has been shaky at times.  Save
> > situations are often forgiving.  That game vs. St.Louis last weekend
> > is a good example.
>
> Yeah, sure, no doubt about that.  Nearly every player has stretches
> during the season where he's not on his game, and Coco isn't airtight
> in the 9th right now.  On the other hand, saying that "they need a
> closer" makes me wonder what team some people are watching.  The Reds'
> other relievers outside Rhodes have been unreliable, the defense at
> shortstop is weak, there's an offensive black hole out in center
> field, and the bats off the bench include Paul Janish and Miguel
> Cairo.  I worry about ALL of that before I worry about a closer who
> has averaged 39 saves the last three years and is on pace to save 51
> games this year.
>
> That's not a bullshit number.  If the save chances keep up, Cordero is
> literally saving games at a rate of 51 for the year.  Even accounting
> for a drop in opportunities, he's almost sure to save 40-plus.  This
> guy ain't the problem.- Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -

I'm not really a count the saves guy. I love this article by Jim
Caple.

http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/page2/story?page=caple/080805

But I agree that there are bigger issues. I wonder how long it will
be before Heisey gets a crack at Stubbs' job. I wonder what happens
when Dickerson gets back.
From: RJA on
On May 20, 6:16 pm, eddyg...(a)msn.com (john smith) wrote:
> Yeah Nix thought he had it and Conrad thought he had caught it because
> he saw it hit Nix's glove. That doesn't change the fact that Nix's glove
> was near the top of the wall or if not above the wall when his glove
> made contact with the ball. It would have been a really nice catch. I
> still say it was going to be a homerun. For a guy like Conrad to drive a
> ball the other way that far off Cordero just makes you scratch your
> head...

Marty and Cowboy (for what it's worth) said it would not have left the
yard. Doesn't matter. It would still have been game tied, runner on
2nd and nobody out.
First  |  Prev  |  Next  |  Last
Pages: 1 2 3
Prev: 33 times first to third this year
Next: damn it !!!