From: jonathan on
On Dec 16, 3:48 pm, Ruben Safir <ru...(a)mrbrklyn.com> wrote:
> On Wed, 16 Dec 2009 11:23:17 -0800, Stewart wrote:
> >  OR Gary Carter.  He had to have more holes in his swing than anyone
> >  ever.
>
> >> Ruben
>
> > Yes, just enough holes for the HOF.
>
> Not when he was with the Mets.  He sucked.  He put his arms way out over
> the plate. standing erect like a statue, in the worse hitting position
> I'd ever seen, forcing the longest back swing I'd ever witnessed,  and
> never made any adjustments, just begging the pitching to throw heat
> inside.  He was the complete opposite of John Orelrud and Rusty Staub who
> were in complete hitting position as soon as the got into the batters
> box, arms cocked in a very powerful but economical swing.
>
> BTW - I would not have voted for Cater to be in the HoF.
>
> Ruben
>
> Ruben

Olerud had the single slowest clocked bat speed nearly every season of
any player on the Blue Jays roster while he was there. Mark Grace
also had a very slow bat. It's amazing what a short swing can do to a
slow bat.
From: Ruben Safir on
On Wed, 16 Dec 2009 12:56:08 -0800, jonathan wrote:


> Olerud had the single slowest clocked bat speed nearly every season of
> any player on the Blue Jays roster while he was there. Mark Grace also
> had a very slow bat. It's amazing what a short swing can do to a slow
> bat.

Don't know where you read that but that didn't prevent him from
slugging .465 lifetime and hitting 255 lifetime HR's. And Toronto had a
big park when he hit 54 doubles and 24 HRs.

One of things I immediately noticed which I saw Carlos Beltran and
Keyspan Park on his rehab is that there is a world of difference between
Beltran's bat speed and the rest of the Class A ballplayers. Beltran has
monumental bat speed.

Ruben
From: Ruben Safir on
On Wed, 16 Dec 2009 21:16:52 +0000, Ruben Safir wrote:

One of things I immediately noticed when I saw Carlos Beltran at
Keyspan Park on his rehab is that there is a world of difference between
Beltran's bat speed and the rest of the Class A ballplayers. Beltran
has monumental bat speed.

From: jonathan on
On Dec 16, 4:16 pm, Ruben Safir <ru...(a)mrbrklyn.com> wrote:
> On Wed, 16 Dec 2009 12:56:08 -0800, jonathan wrote:
> > Olerud had the single slowest clocked bat speed nearly every season of
> > any player on the Blue Jays roster while he was there.  Mark Grace also
> > had a very slow bat.  It's amazing what a short swing can do to a slow
> > bat.
>
> Don't know where you read that but that didn't prevent him from
> slugging .465 lifetime and hitting 255 lifetime HR's.  And Toronto had a
> big park when he hit 54 doubles and 24 HRs.
>
> One of things I immediately noticed which I saw Carlos Beltran and
> Keyspan Park on his rehab is that there is a world of difference between
> Beltran's bat speed and the rest of the Class A ballplayers.  Beltran has
> monumental bat speed.
>
> Ruben

A friend of mine who used to pitch in the Rangers organization was
telling me about it. Basically we were talking about how bat speed is
overrated against a short swing.

Olerud was really good. That was my point. A lot of people think bat
speed tells the whole story but it really doesn't.
From: Stewart on
On 12/16/2009 12:48 PM, Ruben Safir wrote:
> On Wed, 16 Dec 2009 11:23:17 -0800, Stewart wrote:
>
>> OR Gary Carter. He had to have more holes in his swing than anyone
>> ever.
>>>
>>> Ruben
>>
>> Yes, just enough holes for the HOF.
>
>
>
> Not when he was with the Mets. He sucked. He put his arms way out over
> the plate. standing erect like a statue, in the worse hitting position
> I'd ever seen, forcing the longest back swing I'd ever witnessed, and
> never made any adjustments, just begging the pitching to throw heat
> inside. He was the complete opposite of John Orelrud and Rusty Staub who
> were in complete hitting position as soon as the got into the batters
> box, arms cocked in a very powerful but economical swing.
>
>
> BTW - I would not have voted for Cater to be in the HoF.
>
> Ruben
>
> Ruben

He actually had two good years for the Mets and one so-so year
(considering the position he was playing) from '85-'87. After 14 years
behind the plate, he wasn't much for the 5 years he played after that.


http://www.baseball-reference.com/players/c/cartega01.shtml